Page 1 of 1

Is this copy of the Shining VG?

Posted: Tue Feb 04, 2014 2:47 am
by Carter
I really can't stand inaccurate condition grades. ... 20df307078

There is a fine line between opinions solidly within a grade such as VG-, VG, or VG+. But, this is just false advertising. I think eBay should discourage listings like this. Of course, I know they can't police every listing... but in a perfect world.

I mean common, it's an ex library book with water damage!

Re: Is this copy of the Shining VG?

Posted: Tue Feb 04, 2014 4:21 am
by TrueNorth
I thought the same thing. Last week he showed two dust jackets one with the correct price of $8.95 that was falling apart (I mean BAD) and the clipped price he has now. It was strange when I rolled over the pics one would become the other.

IMHO I would rate it Fair to Poor.

Re: Is this copy of the Shining VG?

Posted: Tue Feb 04, 2014 9:49 am
by jhanic
TrueNorth wrote:IMHO I would rate it Fair to Poor.
I agree. With a price-clipped dust jacket and the obvious wear to the book itself, Fair at best.


Re: Is this copy of the Shining VG?

Posted: Tue Feb 18, 2014 8:38 pm
by allasorte
I just signed up and had to reply. Periodically I get laid off, too much, and have found some nice deals and awful ones on e-bay. The one thing good about e-bay is that people put up pictures. Biblio, Abebooks, Alibirs, sellers do not and these sites sellers are asking astronomical amounts for books not even close to worth it. Anyway, I sometimes write to people and ask them specific questions about the book. As a collector, I won't read them so I would want the highest graded book possible. You have no idea how some of these people list inappropriately or even respond wrong. I get so pissed I send the damn book back.

Such as, "are the block pages clean." Of course they say yes or perfect and when you get the book they were either sitting in the sun for years or stained with black dots everywhere. How do you get black stains slash dots on the book? Are they kept in a mildew enclosed basement?

As for the "Shining" ad, people can ask whatever they want, though I think they should not be able for something that is beaten and treated poorly. But if an idiot is willing to pay a lot for something not worth it, then unfortunately let them.